Another game, similar in style to "I wish for". Basically, one player creates a crime, this can be as silly as you want, from thinking Russians are good teammates on dota 2 all the way to murdering people over cookies. The next person has to make it sound innocent, then creates another crime. This repeats.
I'll start.
Poking a nun in the eye.
I'll start.
Poking a nun in the eye.